RSS iconTwitter iconFacebook icon

TrekToday title image

TrekToday - Site Columns

Site Columns

By Michelle
March 11, 2006 - 5:12 PM

Hello World!

I thought this year's Oscars had lots more energy this year than last, from the time Jon Stewart greeted "ladies, gentlemen and Felicity" and said of Capote, "Not all gay people are virile cowboys! Some are effete New York intellectuals!" In general I adored his political jabs ("Bjork couldn't be here tonight because she was trying on her Oscar dress and Dick Cheney shot her," and calling movies about Good Night, and Good Luck a period piece because it was about journalists fighting to expose the truth). My kids were ecstatic when March of the Penguins won for documentary and the producers took the stage carrying big stuffed penguins. I howled at Stewart's comment when Cinderella Man lost best makeup to The Chronicles of Narnia: "Imagine the difficulty of making Russell Crowe look like he got into a fight! ...I'm going to get pummeled for that later." And I was glad both that Ang Lee won and that he talked about what the characters in his film meant to him.

While I am extremely sorry that Brokeback Mountain did not win Best Picture, I am a little flabbergasted at how many people I know who think there was an anti-gay conspiracy. I did not see Crash, so I have no way to assess the relative value of the movie, but I do not believe Brokeback was "robbed" any more than at least twenty better movies I can think of that did not win Best Picture and in some cases were not nominated. Brokeback won Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay, which is one more major award than Kiss of the Spider Woman got in 1986 when Spielberg's watered-down but still worth-seeing The Color Purple didn't even get a director nomination. I think Brokeback Mountain is an excellent film and I really wanted it to win so that it would appear in all the Oscar's Greatest anthologies and the like -- it's a kind of legitimacy to win no matter how stupid the award system itself is. But the fact that self-absorbed L.A. people voted for a self-absorbed L.A. movie doesn't strike me as any sort of conspiracy.

I had to look up 1986 Oscars because I couldn't remember who won Best Actress (Geraldine Page in The Trip to Bountiful). What a year! In addition to overrated Best Picture winner Out of Africa, there were Spider Woman, The Color Purple, Ran, Witness, Brazil, Agnes of God, The Purple Rose of Cairo, Prizzi's Honor, Runaway Train, The Official Story, Jagged Edge, Murphy's Romance, Twice in a Lifetime, Mask...and even the "lighter" fare, Ladyhawke, Silverado, Cocoon, Back to the Future, are all very good movies. It's hard to talk about anyone being robbed when so much was so good. To me Brokeback's loss wasn't like when Shakespeare in Love wound up on top of a mediocre crop in 1999 (I was rooting for Elizabeth, but it was Cate Blanchett who was robbed, not the film). I see typical Academy stupidity but I just don't see a big homophobic conspiracy in a year where Ledger, Gyllenhaal and Felicity Huffman were nominated, Hoffman won, Lee won, McMurtry and Osanna won and Capote and Brokeback were both nominated for the top award.

Trek BBS Today

Below are some of the topics currently being discussed at the Trek BBS:

-Favourite original series staff writer?

-Why are fictional character deaths upsetting to people?

-When did you discover the first Star Trek?

More topics can be found at the Trek BBS!

Trek Two Years Ago

These were some of the major news items from March 2004:

More news can be found in the archives.

Poll Results

Below are the results of the most recent TrekToday poll:


If Aberdeen comes up with the money for a license to use Scotty's image for a public memorial, would you visit?
If I happened to be in Aberdeen anyway. 34.1% - (205 Votes)
Doesn't it make more sense to put that money toward actual engineering advancement? 23.4% - (141 Votes)
I've always wanted to go to Scotland and I'd put it on my list. 21.6% - (130 Votes)
You must be kidding -- travel just to see a Star Trek memorial? 14.9% - (90 Votes)
Scotty isn't from Aberdeen, he's from Elgin! 3.3% - (20 Votes)
It isn't necessary to have a Scotty statue, I'd visit some other sort of memorial. 1.8% - (11 Votes)

Total Votes: 601

Please vote in our new poll on how William Shatner changed the world!

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Discuss this news item at Trek BBS!
XML Add TrekToday RSS feed to your news reader or My Yahoo!
Also a CSI: Crime Scene Investigation fan? Then visit CSIFiles.com!

Find more episode info in the Episode Guide.