Comments on: Okudas: Star Trek: The Next Generation Remastering

By: Frank T.

Frank T. — Mon, 06 Aug 2012 06:52:00 +0000

The Excelsior model in Season One was a stand-in for the Ambassador Class design by Andrew Probert (Enterprise-C displayed on the conference lounge wall display). Because of budget limitations they used the Excelsior model instead. A future “special edition” of TNG will hopefully revisit such scenes, provide us with a VFX option (just like TOS-R) and enable us to see Probert’s Ambassador Class ships as originally intended.
But as Mr. Okuda said, the mission goal for the first Blu-ray release of TNG had been to keep it as close and familar to the original presentation as possible.

By: Kang the Unbalanced

Kang the Unbalanced — Fri, 20 Jul 2012 19:59:00 +0000

Mr. Okuda, while I honestly say I am waiting for the later seasons, I can also honestly say that I am very impressed with the restoration, and even more impressed with the amount of effort that CBS, and you, and all involved have put into it. My only mild disappointment is the removal of the in-jokes on screens and signage. I do sincerely hope that nice, gorgeous, color-corrected images of all the family trees, ship manifests, speed of light speed warnings, Banzai quotes, and other signs of intelligent life will be included in the extras.
Thank you very much for caring.

By: Hamster

Hamster — Fri, 20 Jul 2012 16:21:00 +0000

Well put. I think the overall point Mr. Clements continues to miss is that TV and Film are Aural and Visual media whereby the story along with the visual and audio effects contribute to the overall experience. When one facet is lacking, the overall piece suffers in terms of its impact on the audience.

You guys are doing a wonderful service to us fans and I cannot wait to pick up the blu-ray on its release! I have the sampler disc and it was truly remarkable!

By: Hamster

Hamster — Fri, 20 Jul 2012 16:14:00 +0000

You’re beating a dead horse buddy.

By: Langster

Langster — Thu, 19 Jul 2012 08:48:00 +0000

I totally agree with Hamster’s comment. For me personally, I can’t wait for the blu-ray release of TNG, so I can watch it on my 150 inch projector screen. It is my choice. If you don’t like the blu-ray release then don’t buy it. Simple as that!!!

By: Ireland

Ireland — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 12:48:00 +0000

I don’t understand what the problem with improved visuals is. The storytelling that captured my interest is still there, this is just an improvement in visual quality. Nothing is lost, only gained. With HD we get to see details we never noticed before and have the chance appreciate the art of TNG with a clearer picture. There’s also the possibility that new fans will get into TNG because now that it’s being released in contemporary media. To those complaining about a lack if new stories, that depends on the success of the reboot films. Before Star Trek (2009) our beloved franchise was on a downward spiral and many people were losing interest. LOve it or hate it, the reboot has brought a lot of attention back to Star Trek. If we want to see anything NEW in the Star Trek universe, people have to support the reboots and remastered releases. The unfortunate reality is the studios need to foresee significant profit in pursuing a new television series.

By: Robert Clements

Robert Clements — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 08:22:00 +0000

So in ten years time, with no new stories emerging from the company, you’ll be happy to pay again for the digital 3D edition?

By: Taylør Seidel

Taylør Seidel — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 05:18:00 +0000

Mike Okuda,

I emailed you roughly ten years ago to ask whether you could help provide a tour of the Voyager set for my cousin Brianna, who is blind and hard of hearing. As I recall, you responded to say you were unable to. I was a bit surprised that you actually responded, and I very much appreciated the consideration you gave in responding. With that in mind, I’m not surprised you took the time to respond to Robert Clements. While I don’t share his sentiments, I am amazed that you care about the fans, to the point where you take the time to respond to individual inquires.

With that said, I would like to add in my two cents regarding the remastering of TNG. I bought the Next Level sampler that came out in January, and was immensely impressed with the amount of work that went into rescanning the original raw materials to make the presentation suitable for a resolution of 1920×1080 in a 4:3 aspect ratio. I was also relieved that the 4:3 aspect ratio was retained, as cropping the picture to fit into a 16:9 aspect ratio would have betrayed the director’s vision of the episode, as well as the vision of all the talented people who worked on the show. Having family that works in the film business, I’m keenly aware of the amount of work that goes into a production, whether it be an episode of a TV show, movie, or a commercial. If the original vision can be retained, even honored, then it is a win-win situation for all involved, including the fans.

As someone who is profoundly deaf, I have been fortunate that nearly all of Trek put onto physical media has descriptive audio captions, as well as captions/subtitles on the special features which is not commonplace on other productions. The fact that the special features found on the standard definition discs of the various Star Trek series have closed captioning and/or subtitles is a testament to the thoroughness of the staff who work on putting Trek on physical media. It is my hope that this continues with the Blu-Ray discs.

However, if there was one thing I would like to see in the Blu-Ray set of TNG, it would be an option to add an opaque background to the SDH subtitles. (HD video does not have closed-captioning due to HDMI cords not carrying line 22 that carries captions, in addition to the digital nature of the signal, vs the analog signal found on SD video. This is why SDH subtitles are becoming more prevalent today, because regular subtitles do not have descriptive audio subtitles. example; [PHASERS FIRING] ) Sometimes, if there is a scene that involves snow or a very bright scene set in broad daylight, it can be difficult to read the white/yellow subtitles. Living in a hearing world, I understand that consideration is given to the majority, which means transparent subtitles so that they are less of an annoyance to hearing people, but, such is life for me. I’ve found ways to circumvent this annoyance, but, that’s due to my technical skill. It would be nice of other deaf people had the option to add in an opaque background to the subtitles if they so wished.

Other than that minor issue, I commend the entire staff, including the Okudas, that are dedicated to bringing us an excellent Star Trek series in TNG to high-definition for us to enjoy. I only hope to see DS9 and all the other Star Trek series receive the remastered in HD treatment. I will be buying the TNG S1 Blu-Ray set, and the subsequent seasons released in Blu-Ray, because I admire and respect the work put into bringing this great show to HD.

By: Mike Okuda

Mike Okuda — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 00:29:00 +0000

I hope that if we are able to do DS9 in HD – and the studio is at least thinking about it – you’ll be pleased that CBS’s goal is to honor the original work and to present the original stories and the original characters and the original artistic decisions as you remember them, just sharper, clearer, with more accurate colors, yet true to the original artists’ visions.

Yes, I do think that this is a major advance. In order to present Star Trek: TNG in true HD, CBS undertook a major project to re-scan all of the original film, reconstruct all of the original edits, and rebuild all of the visual effects.

I think that if you’re a fan of Star Trek: The Next Generation – as I am – you’ll see that this is a richer experience because HD restores much of the power of the imagery that was lost in the murkiness of standard definition television.

And if we are so fortunate to be able to do DS9 at some point down the road, I hope you’ll see that your favorite show will be treated with exactly the same care and respect.

By: Hamster

Hamster — Mon, 16 Jul 2012 21:37:00 +0000

There’s no harm in enjoying both… I’m a bit baffled by this age-old argument. First of all, there’s no shortage of Star Trek available in a variety of media (TV, Film, Video Games, Novels, etc…), so it’s hard to argue that it’s a lack of financial commitment to the series that has kept some great stories from coming to fruition. It seems a bit asinine to to say that simply by virtue of wanting to give us the best A/V representation of beloved existing episodes somehow is a stain on the franchise. Good stories and high-quality presentation are, to a large degree, mutually exclusive. I suppose one could say better/more writers could be paid to write new stories, but even that’s a crapshoot anyway. You can hire the best writers/producers/etc… but in the end, even they can turn out a turd. At the end of the day, we’re blessed to have hundreds of outstanding episodes from 5 television series, 11 movies and hundreds of novels. your argument holds no merit. There is nothing wrong with restoring the A/V presentation on the series in-and-of-itself.